Etienne vs. Lawrence: Who is the preseason choice to win ACC Player of the Year?

For those of us in the media who cover the ACC, we were asked to submit our preseason ballot for the Preseason All-ACC team, our predicted order of finish and who we think will be the ACC Player of the Year. Our deadline to turn in our ballots is this evening.

In all, I voted six Clemson players on my Preseason All-ACC Football Team. There is no real surprise who I picked. Five of the six players—quarterback Trevor Lawrence, running back Travis Etienne, left tackle Jackson Carman, defensive tackle Tyler Davis and cornerback Derion Kendrick—were selected at the end of last season as either first- or second-team All-ACC, while one—linebacker James Skalski—was an honorable mention All-ACC pick.

So, picking the All-ACC team was not difficult for me. Neither was picking the order of finish by all 15 teams this year. The top three teams are clearly Clemson, Notre Dame and North Carolina.

But there was a moment of pause when I went to pick my preseason choice for ACC Player of the Year. Do I go with Lawrence or Etienne?

I think the obvious choice is Lawrence. He is the odds-on favorite to win the Heisman Trophy this season. After all, he is the starting quarterback on the top-ranked team in the country. He is also the early bet to be the top pick in next April’s NFL Draft.

But does all of that make Lawrence the ACC Player of the Year?

As we all know, Lawrence has already quarterbacked the Tigers to a national championship and to another title game appearance in his first two years at Clemson. However, in both cases, he did not win ACC Player of the Year honors.

Those honors went to Travis Etienne, who became the first running back in 43 years to win ACC Player of the Year honors in back-to-back seasons, and just the second player in Clemson history to do it, joining Ring of Honor and Hall of Famer Steve Fuller.

So, who did I pick?

Well, I went with Etienne. He likely will break the ACC’s all-time career rushing record this season, which NC State’s Ted Brown has held for 41 years. The Clemson running back already owns the ACC’s career records for rushing touchdowns and total touchdowns.

When it is all said and done, Etienne will likely own several other Clemson and ACC records, as well.

Would I be surprised if Lawrence ultimately won ACC Player of the Year honors? No, not at all. But right now, you have to go with Etienne. I just can’t go against a guy who has already won the award two times.

My All-ACC Preseason Football team, including Player of the Year and predicted order of finish

QUARTERBACK

Trevor Lawrence – QB – Clemson

RUNNING BACK

Travis Etienne – RB – Clemson

Javonte Williams – RB – North Carolina

WIDE RECEIVER

Dazz Newsome – WR/RS – North Carolina

Tamorrion Terry – WR – Florida State

Dyami Brown – WR – North Carolina

TIGHT END

Brevin Jordan – TE – Miami (FL)

ALL-PURPOSE BACK

Hassan Hall – RS – Louisville

OFFENSIVE TACKLE

Jackson Carman – OL – Clemson

Tyler Vrabel – OL – Boston College

OFFENSIVE GUARD

Tommy Kraemer – OL – Notre Dame

Aaron Banks – OL – Notre Dame

CENTER

Jimmy Morrissey – OL – Pittsburgh

DEFENSIVE END

Chris Rumph II – DE – Duke

Carlos Basham Jr. – DL – Wake Forest

DEFENSIVE TACKLE

Tyler Davis – DL – Clemson

Marvin Wilson – DT – Florida State

LINEBACKER

Rayshard Ashby – LB – Virginia Tech

Chazz Surratt – LB – North Carolina

James Skalski – LB – Clemson

CORNERBACK

Derion Kendrick – CB – Clemson

Asante Samuel, Jr. – DB – Florida State

SAFETY

Paris Ford – S – Pittsburgh

Hamsah Nasirildeen – DB – Florida State

PLACEKICKER

Nick Sciba – PK – Wake Forest

PUNTER

Oscar Bradburn – P – Virginia Tech

SPECIALIST

Damond Philyaw-Johnson – WR/RS – Duke

PRESEASON PLAYER OF THE YEAR

Travis Etienne – RB – Clemson

PREDICTED ORDER OF FINISH

1            Clemson

2            Notre Dame

3            North Carolina

4            Louisville

5            Virginia Tech

6            Miami (FL)

7            Pittsburgh

8            Florida State

9            Virginia

10          Wake Forest

11          Duke

12          Boston College

13          NC State

14          Syracuse

15          Georgia Tech

A great gift for any Tiger fan. Just one of many great items available from Clemson Variety & Frame